Montgomery Theft Lawyer

Top-Rated Theft Attorney in Montgomery, AL

If you are facing theft charges in Alabama, your freedom and future are on the line. A conviction can leave you with serious penalties. It is wise to partner with a Skilled Montgomery theft lawyer at Luck Law, LLC to aggressively protect your rights.

Luck Law, LLC: Your Montgomery Theft Lawyer

For more than 30 years, Terry Luck at Luck Law, LLC has advocated for clients facing serious criminal charges across the Yellowhammer State. While past results never guarantee future outcomes, we are here to challenge the state’s evidence and build a strong defense case on your behalf.

Alabama Theft Law Basics

Alabama’s theft laws categorize this offense into four degrees based on the monetary value of the items stolen. Theft charges are handled as part of our broader criminal defense practice at Luck Law, LLC.

• First Degree. This is a Class B felony if convicted. The property value must exceed $2,500, be taken directly from a person, or involve a motor vehicle. The maximum penalty is 2 to 20 years in prison and/or fines up to $30,000.
• Second Degree. A Class C Felony, if convicted. The criteria are theft of property valued at $1,500 to $2,500, or any firearm, controlled substance, or livestock. The maximum penalty is 1 to 10 years in prison and/or fines up to $15,000.
• Third Degree. A Class D Felony, if convicted. The property value is $500 to $1,499, or any credit/debit card. The maximum penalty is 1 to 5 years in prison and/or fines up to $7,500.
• Fourth Degree. A Class A Misdemeanor, if convicted. The property value is $500 or less, which is why this degree of theft in Alabama is often referred to as petty theft. The maximum penalty is up to 1 year in jail and/or fines up to $6,000.

Alabama Convictions

In Alabama, the prosecution bears the entire burden of proof for a theft crime offense. The following are true:

• Defendants are presumed innocent.
• Defendants do not have to present any evidence.
• Defendants are not required to prove their own innocence.

To secure a conviction, the state must meet the highest legal standard: proving guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. They must prove:

• The defendant knowingly obtained, exerted control over, or took the property of another person without their permission.
• The defendant intended to permanently deprive the rightful owner of their property. Temporary use or honest mistakes do not satisfy this standard.
• The exact fair market value of the items is required to prove the specific degree of a felony level theft being charged. If the state cannot verify a specific dollar value, the charge must be reduced to fourth-degree theft (a misdemeanor), unless the item is in an automatic felony category like a firearm, motor vehicle, or credit card.

Crime in Context

Theft of property in the first degree was the second highest number of felony convictions sentenced in the state in 2023, with 1,258 convictions. When facing theft charges, understanding the local culture is critical. High area crime rates mean local police and prosecutors are under immense pressure to secure convictions. This escalates the stakes for any person accused of an offense. At Luck Law, LLC, we understand how much is on the line, and we work to protect your freedom.

Reasons to Hire Luck Law, LLC

A seasoned attorney at Luck Law, LLC targets the gaps in the state’s evidence to show the high burden of proof has not been met. Common defense strategies include:

• Challenging Intent. Introducing evidence of a good-faith belief of ownership, an honest mistake, or a misunderstanding regarding permission to use the property.
• Disputing Identification. Questioning the reliability of blurry surveillance footage or eyewitnesses to show the state cannot conclusively prove the identity of the alleged thief.
• Contesting Property Value. Forcing the state to substantiate valuation claims. If the defense successfully proves an item’s market value is lower than alleged, a felony charge can be reduced to a misdemeanor.

Each theft case is unique, and it is worth speaking with a skilled lawyer about your individual charges.

Speak Directly
With An Attorney
Today

Schedule A Consultation

FAQs

Are There Any Special Theft Offenses in Alabama?

Yes, there are some special theft offenses in Alabama. These include:

• Shoplifting. Shoplifting items whose value is under $500 is a Class A misdemeanor. However, a fourth or subsequent shoplifting conviction is automatically elevated to a Class C felony, even if the stolen merchandise is of low value.
• Receiving Stolen Property. Under Alabama Code § 13A-8-16, knowingly possessing, retaining, or discarding stolen items is a crime with the same value-based tier structure and consequences as standard theft.

How Much Does It Cost to Hire a Lawyer for a Theft Offense?

It is difficult to provide reliable information about the cost of hiring a lawyer for a theft offense because all Alabama lawyers may determine their own attorney rates. Lawyers base their fee agreements on their experience level, the amount of time they expect to spend on your theft case, and other case-specific and attorney-specific factors. If you need a lawyer, inquire about their written fee agreement. 

What Type of Evidence Is Often Used in a Theft Case?

A wide variety of evidence may be used in a theft case. This may include:

• Surveillance footage, such as security camera recordings, residential doorbell cameras, or surrounding parking lot systems.
• Digital records, such as bank statements, time-stamped electronic receipts, or point-of-sale transaction logs.
• Mobile tracking, like cell phone location data and GPS tracking details.
• Physical and forensic evidence.
• Testimonial evidence, like eyewitness accounts.
• Documentary evidence, such as value verification, payroll documentation, and corporate logs.

Can I Handle My Own Theft Defense?

While you can handle your own theft defense in Alabama, it is not recommended that you do so. Working with an attorney is the most effective way to protect your rights. Working without a lawyer means taking a significant risk when your freedom is on the line. There are nearly 2 million people incarcerated across 98 federal and 1,566 state prisons in the U.S. An attorney builds a strong defense to help protect your future.

Montgomery Theft Related Resources:

• How Alabama’s Criminal Defense Process Works: A Step-by-Step Guide for 2026
• Statute of Limitations for Criminal Charges

Hire a Theft Lawyer in Montgomery: Choose Luck Law, LLC

To hire a theft lawyer, connect with our law firm. When you need help navigating the 15^th Judicial Circuit of Alabama, locals across Montgomery trust Luck Law, LLC for their criminal defense. Our Montgomery theft attorney’s knowledge of Alabama’s theft laws is unparalleled. He brings this knowledge to every client’s theft case. Contact us to schedule your initial consultation.