Four Common Defenses to Criminal Charges in Montgomery County

Terry Luck • April 1, 2023
Four Common Defenses to Criminal Charges in Montgomery County

Four Common Defenses to Criminal Charges in Montgomery County

If you are charged with a crime, the law presumes you are innocent until proven guilty. The law also provides you with the opportunity to defend yourself against the allegations to prevent the prosecutor from proving your case. 


In criminal cases, there are many possible defenses, though some are more common than others. You should always hire a criminal defense attorney in Montgomery County who can identify all the defenses that can help you avoid a conviction whenever possible. Never wait to contact Luck Law LLC, so we can begin building the strongest possible defense. 


Below are some examples of defenses that are common in criminal cases:


1. Self Defense

Self-defense is a criminal defense used in cases involving assault or other acts of violence. Similar defenses involve claiming the defense of others or property. Alabama also has Stand Your Ground laws in place that can assist with a self-defense claim. 


If you are pleading self-defense, you are claiming that you harmed or killed another individual to protect your own life against the violent threats of another individual. Unfortunately, many people misunderstand how self-defense works. A successful self-defense claim requires complex legal analysis and evidence, which is why you need a skilled attorney to present this defense for you. 


2. Insanity

Insanity defenses are affirmative defenses, and they apply in rare cases. Your lawyer must plead this defense early in your case for it to apply. Alabama puts the burden of proof on the defendant to prove that they should not be accountable for their actions because:


  • At the time of the offense
  • The defendant could not distinguish between right and wrong
  • Or otherwise could not understand their conduct
  • Due to a disease of the mind


Unfortunately, insanity defenses are incredibly challenging to prove because your claim needs to demonstrate that you did not know right from wrong when you committed the crime. This often requires extensive expert analysis, and even if successful, this defense will likely lead to a different set of consequences, such as commitment to a mental hospital instead of prison. 


3. Constitutional Violations

Under the U.S. Constitution, you’re entitled to some protections regardless of whether you committed a crime. Further, any evidence stemming from constitutional violations should be suppressed from your case. When authorities violate your constitutional rights, your lawyer might be able to use it as an important part of your defense. 


For example, many individuals are improperly searched, arrested, or questioned by the police. Some of the most common constitutional violations include obtaining a coerced confession, not obtaining a warrant, not having justification for a stop or arrest, and not reading Miranda warnings upon arrest. 


If an attorney can prove your constitutional rights were violated, your attorney can seek to have all resulting evidence kept out of your case. Often, this can result in a dismissal of charges if the prosecutor has little other evidence to prove your charges. 


4. Innocence

Some people did not commit the crime they are accused of. Your defense lawyer can help gather evidence to support your innocence, including:


  • An alibi
  • Improper witness identification
  • False allegations
  • Planted evidence
  • Malicious prosecution


Speak With A Montgomery County Criminal Defense Lawyer Today To Discuss Your Case

Always consult a Montgomery County criminal defense attorney about your case if you have been charged with a crime. At Luck Law LLC, we help our clients build strong criminal defenses to prove their innocence or keep them out of jail. Please contact us here for more information.


Your Right to Stand Your Ground in Alabama - Read More!

Terry's Tips

A lawyer in a courtroom presenting evidence to a seated jury while pointing at a large notepad on an
By Terry Luck December 1, 2025
A lawyer presents key evidence to a jury during a courtroom trial, highlighting the legal process and professional courtroom proceedings. Ideal for legal, attorney, and trial-related content.
An insurance or accident investigator speaking with a distressed woman wearing a reflective safety
By Terry Luck December 1, 2025
An investigator reviews details of a car accident while speaking with a witness at the crash site, capturing the evaluation process after a vehicle collision. Suitable for personal injury, insurance, and accident-related content.
Commercial Truck Accidents & Manslaughter Charge
By Terry Luck November 2, 2025
Find out when commercial truck accidents can lead to manslaughter charges and how a defense lawyer can protect your rights.
Why Prosecutors Should Consider Autism in Court Cases
By Terry Luck November 1, 2025
Learn why recognizing autism in criminal proceedings is crucial for fair outcomes, informed decisions, and justice that considers every defendant’s unique challenges.
What Happens If Arrested at a Car or Truck Accident
By Terry Luck October 2, 2025
Find out what to expect if you're arrested at the scene of a car or truck wreck. Learn your rights and the steps to take immediately after the accident.
Autism in Courtrooms
By Terry Luck October 1, 2025
Learn how courts can ensure fair trials for neurodivergent defendants with autism by addressing their unique needs, communication challenges, and rights.
Reckless Driving vs Negligence After a Car Crash Explained
By Terry Luck September 1, 2025
Learn how Alabama law distinguishes reckless driving from negligence after a car crash and why the difference matters for your injury claim and legal rights.
How Terry Luck Champions Justice for Clients with Autism
By Terry Luck September 1, 2025
Learn how attorney Terry Luck advocates for justice, providing compassionate legal support and dedicated representation for clients on the autism spectrum.
Show More